South Carolina Man Gets 30 Years for Stepson’s Murder

A Greenwood County jury convicted William Bryan Morgan after an eight-day trial over the 2021 shooting death of Caleb Donnelly.

GREENWOOD, SC — A South Carolina man was sentenced to 30 years in prison after a jury found him guilty of murdering his 29-year-old stepson following a series of domestic disputes in June 2021, according to the 8th Judicial Circuit Solicitor’s Office.

William Bryan Morgan, 36, was convicted Nov. 18 of murder in the death of Caleb Donnelly. The jury deliberated for about two hours after an eight-day trial before returning its verdict. Circuit Judge Thomas William McGee III then sentenced Morgan to 30 years in prison. Prosecutors said the sentence must be served without the possibility of parole under South Carolina law.

The case began with a domestic dispute involving Morgan and Donnelly at a party at another residence in June 2021, prosecutors said. Greenwood County sheriff’s deputies responded and eventually took Donnelly back to the place where he was living, a small outbuilding behind Morgan’s home. Authorities said the move was intended to separate the two men and calm the situation.

Deputies were called back a short time later after Donnelly damaged property inside Morgan’s home, according to prosecutors. While deputies spoke with Donnelly’s mother, Morgan returned to the property. Prosecutors said Morgan retrieved a .357 Magnum revolver and went looking for Donnelly.

Authorities told Donnelly’s mother that deputies had enough information to seek an arrest warrant over the property damage, according to the solicitor’s office. Prosecutors said deputies believed an arrest could keep Donnelly in custody through the weekend while relatives sought help related to his mental illness. The warrant had not been obtained before the fatal shooting.

After deputies left the property, they were called there for a third time when Donnelly was found dead in the outbuilding where he lived, prosecutors said. Morgan left the area after the shooting and was located two days later as he emerged from woods near his home.

During an interview with investigators, Morgan admitted shooting Donnelly several times, according to the solicitor’s office. Prosecutors said Morgan told investigators that he fired a final shot because he wanted to put Donnelly “out of his misery.” The statement became part of the prosecution’s account of the killing at trial.

Solicitor David M. Stumbo said after sentencing that Morgan had “hunted down and killed a family member” after growing tired of dealing with symptoms of Donnelly’s mental illness. Stumbo said Donnelly deserved compassion from relatives he trusted and said his office would continue seeking accountability in cases involving vulnerable victims.

Deputy Solicitor Yates Brown and Assistant Solicitor Madison Hoffman prosecuted the case with assistance from 8th Circuit Investigator Dyar Archibald and victim advocate Rhetta Smith. Morgan was represented by attorneys Rose Mary Parham, Shipp Daniel and Ray Chandler, according to the solicitor’s office.

Morgan is now serving the 30-year sentence imposed after his murder conviction. The solicitor’s office said the prison term must be served day for day and carries no possibility of parole.

Author note: Last updated November 22, 2026.